fbpx
Politics Foreign Affairs Culture Fellows Program

After 12 Years, A Farewell To This Blog

The end of an era, but the start of a new one at Rod Dreher's Diary, my Substack newsletter
Screen Shot 2023-02-24 at 9.05.37 PM

Big changes coming here to TAC. After a glorious run of almost twelve years, this blog is coming to an end on this website. We expect it to wind down sometime in the next two weeks. Nothing bad happened, and I'm not leaving TAC; I will stay on as editor at large, and will probably contribute a column. It's just that TAC's strategy is changing a bit, and so will my role at the magazine.

I will continue my culture war coverage at Rod Dreher's Diary, my subscriber-only Substack newsletter. You might know that I have been writing a twice-weekly separate Substack newsletter that focuses on religion, books, and other things seen very much not through the culture war lens. That will continue, but I will now make it a daily newsletter, writing about politics, the culture war, and all the things that I blog about here. If you already subscribe to Rod Dreher's Diary, all this means is that you will soon be getting a daily dispatch. Because so many of you have told me you like reading the non-culture war stuff I write about art, religion, literature, and so forth, I will keep doing that, but will give those dispatches a specific title, so you can safely ignore the culture war and politics stuff that you don't like (or dip into it if you want to walk on the wild side).

Advertisement

I know that many, many of you hated the loss of this blog's comments section when the site redesign happened. Well, the good news is that you can comment to your heart's delight on the Substack, if you're a subscriber. I have found that the comments section there now works well without me having to moderate to keep trolls off. If people pay five dollars a month for content, they're the kind of people who can be counted on not to troll or be otherwise abusive. And if somehow trolls make it onto the site, I'll just cancel their subscription. I hope readers who stepped away from this blog because you could not comment, and the fun, smart, engaging comments section went away, will consider subscribing to Rod Dreher's Diary, and reviving the feature that we all loved so much -- and re-establishing contact with old friends.

By the way, Rod Dreher's Diary charges the minimum price that Substack will allow: five dollars per month, or fifty dollars per year. If you want to support me at a higher level, you have that option too. It's something I would appreciate for those with the means to do so, because it's scary to be leaving my safe institutional home for the past twelve years.

About these past twelve years: In my 34 years as a professional journalist, TAC is the place where I have worked the longest. I've been here through a succession of editors, all of whom have treated me with great kindness, respect, and support. The late, great Wick Allison, TAC's former publisher, hired me in the summer of 2011, and when my sister died of cancer, he agreed to let me work from south Louisiana, where my wife and I felt called to move. That was characteristically generous of him, and I've had that kind of professional and personal support from everybody at TAC since then. It really is a dream for a writer to be paid actual money and given the freedom to write whatever he wants. Life at TAC has been, for me, living the dream. I'm so grateful to all of those who made it possible for me -- my TAC colleagues, past and present, and all you readers and subscribers.

Here's what this blog has done for me professionally: my blogging about my late sister's battle with cancer turned into The Little Way of Ruthie Leming. My blogging about Dante turned into How Dante Can Save Your Life. My blogging about the Benedict Option turned into The Benedict Option. The massive amount of coverage I've given to wokeness and the culture war turned into Live Not By Lies. I owe my career as a writer of books to this blog, and this magazine, and what you readers have given to me over the years. Thank you.

And Walker Percy Weekend! It was organized in part on this here blog.

Advertisement

I think the greatest hit ever on this blog was the July 2016 interview I did with the first-time writer J.D. Vance, about his new book Hillbilly Elegy. The book had been out for a few weeks, and had done okay in sales, but looked like it might be reaching the end of its run. One of this blog's readers bought me a Kindle copy of the book, and said I should read it. I did, on a flight to Boston, and was blown away. I reached out to J.D. and asked for an interview. He gave it to me. I published it on this blog ... and everything exploded. It went viral, melting down the server twice that weekend. Eventually over two million people read that interview. Suddenly, Hillbilly Elegy rocketed up the bestseller charts, where it stayed for many weeks, selling in the millions. A feature film was made of it. And now, our friend J.D. is US Senator Vance. I expect great things from him, because I've gotten to know him personally over the years since then, and believe him to be a genuinely good man. What a privilege it was to have been there right at the beginning of what I think will be an extraordinary political career of a young man upon whom the future of America may one day depend. It was all thanks to TAC, and thanks to you readers.

So, look: I will still be blogging in this space for the next two weeks, but if you are inclined to keep reading my reporting and commentary on the culture war, religion, politics, Dreher Bait, and so forth, I really do hope you will go over to the Rod Dreher's Diary page and subscribe right now. If I don't get enough subscribers to replace the lost income from my TAC blogging, I'll have to figure something else out. (If you are a current subscriber, you don't need to do anything; that won't change, no matter what.) If you do subscribe between now and the expanded Rod Dreher's Diary launch in a couple of weeks, and I end up not having enough new subscribers to make a daily mailing feasible, then I will refund your subscription. So, no risk.

I'm also going to try some new things with the Substack format that I wasn't able to do here. I hope to reproduce everything that you like about this blog, but also add some new stuff. It'll be fun, and I hope you'll be part of this new chapter in my writing life.

I also hope you'll still keep coming to TAC to see what our writers and contributors are saying and doing. TAC has been an important voice on the American scene for over twenty years. It can only keep on keeping on with your readership, your donations, and your subscriptions. I may not be here in the format that you're used to reading me, but I'm still going to be part of Team TAC, and I hope you will be too.

Remember: this blog continues for the next two weeks. Once I see people moving over to Rod Dreher's Diary, I'll start ramping up copy there too. Happy to receive your goodbyes-and-good-luck and your good-riddances at rod -- at -- amconmag -- dot -- com, if you'd like to send any.

Who knows? Maybe we can bring the great Uncle Chuckie (see him with me below) out of hiding on the Substack. And come back, Siarlys! And Franklin and Jon F. (also pictured below)!

Comments

Want to join the conversation?

Subscribe for as little as $5/mo to start commenting on Rod’s blog.

Join Now
JON FRAZIER
JON FRAZIER
Hey, I never left. Though getting Uncle Chuckie back would be cause for Hosannas.
schedule 1 year ago
Chris Karr
Chris Karr
Good for you - best wishes for success over at Substack-land.
schedule 1 year ago
Fran Macadam
Fran Macadam
I feel like I've just been sideswiped, because I just subscribed to TAC to be able to comment again. It was not easy to justify because of our financial circumstances, either. I guess there's more than meets the eye to this. As the worst war in my lifetime looms, I hope this is not a harbinger of TAC policies moving towards my country, wrong or right, but that consideration surely is in the works as official war nears.
schedule 1 year ago
    Peter Pratt
    Peter Pratt
    My thoughts as well. My subscription goes through July, but I will likely cancel before that. I still like the mag, but I can go without commenting.
    schedule 1 year ago
    PJ
    PJ
    Ditto. I just subscribed at the beginning of the year to comment again. Ah well. None of the other writers at TAC have hooked me on reading as much as Rod. (well, Larrison did before he departed but none of the current ones.)
    schedule 1 year ago
    Mario Diana
    Mario Diana
    Rod’s blog is 99 percent of the reason I come to this site—and have been since before the “Benedict Option” days. Why do I suspect this was a contract negotiation standoff that ended with no deal. That’s unfortunate.
    schedule 1 year ago
      Theodore Iacobuzio
      Theodore Iacobuzio
      You mean you don't come here for the trenchant analysis of Declan Leary, the Tertullian of the Two-Toilet Irish? What riches!
      schedule 1 year ago
John Phillips
John Phillips
Good luck Rod. You will be successful where ever you go. You are a workaholic!
schedule 1 year ago
Bogdán Emil
Bogdán Emil
This is horrible. I can't even finish reading this post.

Well, TAC is the stupidest when it comes to smart decisions, huh?

Absurd.

See you on Substack, to hell with this. There is no other writer who engages like you.

What's the point of commenting on trite articles by people I don't want to be friends with?

TAC is next to nothing without this blog. Utter and complete fools, as I puke the words.
schedule 1 year ago
    Fran Macadam
    Fran Macadam
    I honestly don't see the difference in commenting policy between a site that requires subscriptions to comment or even see comments, and another that requires the same exact model.
    There's no doubt Rod's columns here have grown to an extraordinary length. It would have been a virtue to have reduced the quantity of each, without losing either the quality or frequency. It must be tiring to write at such length and truth be told that resulted in speed reading and skimming.
    schedule 1 year ago
      Bogdán Emil
      Bogdán Emil
      Fran, Rod loves to write and we love to read it.

      Nonsubscribers can see these comments. This is a website frequented by the world.

      This is a loss for all of us, but maybe something good will come of it.
      schedule 1 year ago
        Fran Macadam
        Fran Macadam
        Have you checked out comments on other contributors' articles? For several, there are no comments displayed until you login. This is a feature of the new system. For those, non members will only see the article, not any comments.
        schedule 1 year ago
Bernie
Bernie
I never left either, Jon! Rod, I see a huge opportunity for you in your new Substack. I look forward to commenting on it and I wish you all the best.
schedule 1 year ago
MPC
MPC
I have appreciated engaging with you and other commenters over the years, Rod. And the space to print some of my own long winded thoughts. Best wishes and sooner or later I am sure I will make the migration over to your Substack.
schedule 1 year ago
Frans
Frans
This post doesn’t really explain why you decided to leave and/or why the organization decided that you should, or even which of the two it was. In fact it largely seems to purposely skirt the issue.

What are the “big changes” translating into “a bit of a strategy shift” at TAC? Can you or someone else from the organization elaborate?
schedule 1 year ago
Giuseppe Scalas
Giuseppe Scalas
That's really sad news. As a foreigner, I subscribe to TAC because Rod's articles, although America-centered, have really worldwide relevance.
And although I appreciate the articles of other authors too, I'm afraid that's not enough to continue with a subscription. Let's see.
This will really depend upon how much TAC stays relevant to the cause of National Conservatism, which I support.
Because, let's be very clear: America is an Empire and most European nations in its sphere of influence have limited sovereignty. Therefore, if I want National Conservatism to be successful in my own Country, I must want it to be successful in the US, with people such as Vance and DeSantis.
So, will TAC be able to stay relevant without Rod? Let's wait and see.
schedule 1 year ago
    Fran Macadam
    Fran Macadam
    It's relevant to a national American conservatism, the reason it was established, as against neocon imperialism like that of National Review.
    However, others haven't quite found their voice here yet leading to a popularity like Rod Dreher's.
    Mentioning Daniel Larison, I still read and correspond with him, but his column put him in the company of Never-Trumpers. Rod is similarly inclined, even to the point of almost believing the Maddow style phoney Russiagate hoaxes.
    Given that Trump has emerged as the only credible extreme critic of the American-Ukraine war that is lurching towards nuclear exchange, it is probably not in the interests of the magazine's mission to have an author who is conflicted about the war who would undermine the only credible, populist antiwar political leader, especially when Rod Dreher is the site's most popular writer.
    I do not see any other emerging Republican candidates yet who do not at least support the war, yet TAC was founded on just such a principle during the mad enthusiasm and false propaganda for the Iraq war. I don't think it is understood yet how neatly this war plays into corporate Woke delusions.
    schedule 1 year ago
      Bogdán Emil
      Bogdán Emil
      Very interesting theory.
      schedule 1 year ago
    JON FRAZIER
    JON FRAZIER
    Giuseppe, I hope you will migrate to Substack!
    schedule 1 year ago
Jonesy
Jonesy
My budget is growing thin from all my subscriptions. I really enjoy your blog Rod but I just can’t swing another subscription.
schedule 1 year ago
    Bogdán Emil
    Bogdán Emil
    Cancel something else, do it
    schedule 1 year ago
Peter Kurilecz
Peter Kurilecz
well at least through feedly i'll have access to all your past blog postings yes all 12 years. well now to head over and subscribe to the substack. i've been following you for almost 20 years (I think) and I can't stop now
schedule 1 year ago
Martin Terrell
Martin Terrell
Good luck. I mainly subscribed to TAC for this blog, and look forward to following in Substack. I like the comments too, and hope there’ll be informative and appreciate commentary from Rod’s extended family. And if nothing else there’ll be a proper comment function on Substack. This one is still terrible.
schedule 1 year ago