Home/Daniel Larison/The Dangerous Delusions of Iran Hawks

The Dangerous Delusions of Iran Hawks

While he was justifying the killing of Soleimani today, Mike Pompeo made one of the more breathtakingly delusional statements he has made as Secretary of State:

If Pompeo genuinely expects Iranians to be grateful to America that our military killed one of their most popular and respected commanders, he is in for quite a shock. This statement fits a larger pattern of the administration’s complete lack of understanding of Iran and its internal politics. The vast majority of Iranians today views the U.S. unfavorably, and almost the same number had a favorable view of Soleimani. According to last survey’s University of Maryland survey, 82% of Iranians had a favorable opinion of Soleimani. 59% held a very favorable view of him. Killing him will not only intensify anti-American sentiment in the country, but it will very likely make Soleimani even more popular in death than he was in life. In what universe would people celebrate the killing of one of their war heroes by a hated foreign power?

As we would expect, many Iranians are mourning him en masse:

In the real world, there will likely be a surge of Iranian nationalism in response, and the government is going to encourage that however it can. The government is going to use this to smother dissent and continue the violent crackdown against protesters that has been taking place in recent months, and they will presumably use national security as a pretext for further curtailing Iranians’ freedom. Just as the economic war has harmed Iranian political activists and impoverished the civilian population, a U.S.-Iran war is going to create even more suffocating internal conditions. Hard-liners are going to flourish in the new political landscape at the expense of both protesters and advocates for engagement.

Pompeo’s cartoon ideological view of Iran has nothing to do with the reality. The danger is that the president and his top officials know so little about the real Iran that every action they take is bound to boomerang and create more problems for the U.S. The administration talks and acts as if they expect Iranians to welcome and approve acts of war against their country, and so they are completely unprepared for the overwhelmingly negative and hostile reaction that results. Americans and Iranians alike are going to be paying the price for their clueless arrogance for a long time to come.

about the author

Daniel Larison is a senior editor at TAC, where he also keeps a solo blog. He has been published in the New York Times Book Review, Dallas Morning News, World Politics Review, Politico Magazine, Orthodox Life, Front Porch Republic, The American Scene, and Culture11, and was a columnist for The Week. He holds a PhD in history from the University of Chicago, and resides in Lancaster, PA. Follow him on Twitter.

leave a comment

Latest Articles