fbpx
Politics Foreign Affairs Culture Fellows Program

Today In Trans Tyranny

Irish Evangelical teacher in pronoun dispute -- and State Department now spying on countries for evidence of trans 'hate'
Today In Trans Tyranny

This happened in Ireland. Ireland!:

A teacher in Ireland has been suspended from work and then jailed for contempt of court after he refused to use the correct pronouns to address a transgender student.

Enoch Burke was arrested on Monday for violating a court order barring him from teaching at Wilson’s Hospital School in Westmeath, or even being present there, the news site RTE.ie reported.

Judge Michael Quinn found Burke guilty of violating an order made by the High Court last week and sent him to Mountjoy Prison, where he will remain until either he purges his contempt or the court gives further orders.

Advertisement

The RTE report makes clear that Burke was not jailed for his pronoun usage, but rather for refusing the court's order to stay away from the school. That's a meaningful difference! Still, it is insane that this ridiculous pronoun stuff has come to this. Had Burke obeyed the court's order, he would have kept his freedom, and the school likely would have gotten away with quietly firing him. Firing a teacher who wouldn't engage in a practice nobody ever heard of until the day before yesterday. Destroying the career of a teacher who refused to live by lies. It is true that Burke comes from a family of cantankerous Evangelicals who love public protest, and who may not be the most sympathetic campaigners to many. Again, though, Ireland is now a country where a teacher's refusal to conform to pronoun insanity gets him suspended from his job.

I've mentioned in this space before that traveling throughout the former Communist nations of Europe, I keep running into people who have come to hate America, which they correctly identify as the source of gender ideology. They believe -- again, correctly -- that this stuff is being forced on their unwilling societies via cultural imperialism: through Big Business, and through the US Government's initiatives.

Leor Sapir, writing at City Journal, reports that the US State Department is turning American diplomatic outposts into staging areas for the culture war against backwards foreigners who won't join the Gender Identity Revolution:

Is the U.S. State Department about to classify Sweden, Finland, and the U.K. as human rights abusers? According to an internal memo from Secretary Antony Blinken (leaked to me by an officer in the department’s Foreign Service) and circulated among employees last week, the answer might be yes.

The memo represents an effort by Secretary Blinken to carry out President Biden’s Executive Order 14075 from last June. That order instructs agencies of the federal government to do what they can to stop “conversion therapy” for “LGBTQI+” people. Following its release, Biden appointed Jessica Stern as Special Envoy to Advance the Human Rights of LGBTQI+ Persons, a position created by the Obama administration but left unfilled under Donald Trump. Stern, who goes by “all pronouns,” had previously served as executive director at OutRight Action International, an advocacy organization with a permanent presence at United Nations headquarters in New York. OutRight has borrowed arguments against “conversion therapy” for sexual orientation (where the evidence against the practice is strong) and applied them, unscientifically, to “gender identity” (where studies have consistently shown that cross-gender identification in children is, for the vast majority of those who experience it, a passing phase). This strategy of piggybacking off public ignorance about the difference between homosexuality and transgenderism is by now familiar. And lest it be thought that politicians know better, Biden himself seems unable to differentiate between sexual orientation and gender identity.

The Biden administration has defined “conversion therapy” as any effort to “suppress or change an individual’s . . . gender identity.” The Blinken memo cites as an authority the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, an organization that, like the American Academy of Pediatrics, has fallen victim to capture by a small but vocal and well-organized group of ideologues, among them Jack Turban. The memo relies on the United Nations Independent Expert on sexual orientation and gender identity, Victor Madrigal-Borloz, to clarify that “conversion” means only efforts to change a transgender identity into a “cisgender one.” Thus, a hypothetical scenario in which a child is put under intense pressure to become trans, even if this means medicalization, would technically not count as “conversion.” At the first signs of a child’s gender distress or confusion, the only legitimate, “human rights”-respecting outcome of treatment, according to the Biden administration, is social transition followed, in most cases, by body modification.

More:

Advertisement

Ominously, the Blinken memo defines “conversion therapy” to include not only “electric shock” and “corrective rape” but also “talk therapy.” That’s right: using psychotherapy to help a child in distress about her changing body feel more comfortable in it rather than undergo expensive, risky, and irreversible hormonal and surgical interventions is, according to the State Department, no different from electrocuting gays and lesbians in order to “liberate” them from their innate sexual attractions.

The problem, for countries like Sweden, Finland, and the U.K., is that medical authorities in these places have concluded over the past two years that the evidence for pediatric “gender affirming care” is extremely weak and that, as a result, hormonal and surgical interventions are (as Finland’s COHERE put it) “experimental.” Sweden and Finland are now instructing clinicians who deal with minors to utilize an approach that emphasizes talk therapy as the first line of defense and “affirming” drugs only in extreme situations, if ever. Sweden has banned gender surgeries for minors—surgeries that are practiced in the United States, notwithstanding the repeated gaslighting of gender clinics and left-of-center media outlets.

The Blinken directive effectively turns American consulates and embassies into global “gender affirming” spies. Embassies are instructed to “submit robust information on the so-called ‘conversion therapy’ practices” of host countries “as part of the annual Human Rights Reports.” Jessica Stern’s office will then devise an “action plan to combat the practice across foreign policy and foreign assistance lines of effort.”

Read the whole thing. We are becoming an Evil Empire. Older people I talk to in the former Soviet bloc countries tend to talk about what's happened to America lately with sadness and incomprehension. Inevitably they'll say something like, "What happened to you? We used to look at you as a sign of hope."

More on the State Department's weaponization of diplomacy for the culture war: five years ago, I posted documents sent to me by a Fulbright scholar, from his State Department training before being sent to a very conservative Third World country. He said that all the scholarship winners that year had been subjected to lengthy lectures by the State Department on how their job was to go abroad to spread the gospel of LGBT rights -- this, even though it had nothing to do with the Fulbright program, and in many cases would be diametrically opposed to the cultural views of countries the American scholars were headed to. Respect for the Fulbright scholars' host countries didn't matter to the State Department. What mattered above all things was that these US-funded scholars become ambassadors for the cultural revolution. As the Fulbrighter who sent me images of the training documents said:

What I would like to emphasize is that these SJW ideology sessions took fully 1/3 of our day. This was time that could have been spent talking about the religion or culture or history of the regions we’re going to–many Fulbrighters have never been to the country they’ll be doing their research in, and could absolutely use a primer. Yet the State Department decided it was more important to stick self-described LGBT activists on a stage than it was to give people a meaningfully informative orientation about the region.

That was 2016. Heaven only knows how bad it is today.

Comments

Become a Member today for a growing stake in the conservative movement.
Join here!
Join here
Michael Cullinan
Michael Cullinan
I remember when Obama stood in an African country and criticized the continent for not having SSM like the US. Not only did they see that as grossly undiplomatic, but absoluely insane. Now we want them to think that a man becomes a woman by simple delaration.

No wonder they've gone over to China.
schedule 3 weeks ago
Michael Campbell
Michael Campbell
It's interesting how few questions the corporate-skeptical lefties out there ask about the absolute piggy bank of treatments for vulnerable kids, propagandized and stuffed full of surgery and hormones and drugs for the rest of their life.

US "experts" would never overprescribe something lucrative for a treatment, would they?

Scandinavian countries looking much saner. With how transitory gender dysphoria often is, something we know, it's really criminal to not go for the simplest interventions first before horrifically invasive ones with irreversible damage.

Who do we believe on health matters, the country that happily did lockdowns and school closures and completely ignored the catastrophic costs, disporportionately borne by the weakest and most marginalized, and that barely even recognizes the word "myocarditis"? Or the country that did not do lockdowns, long term school closures, masks on kids, etc., doesn't even recommend Covid shots for young kids, and banned Moderna outright - because of myocarditis - among younger adults?

Sweden is once again right, US progressives are not, the question is how many years and how many lives ruined will it take before the general public realizes again how wrong US progressives are and forces them to stop?
schedule 3 weeks ago
    Michael Campbell
    Michael Campbell
    Neocons are to US foreign policy what progressives are to US domestic policy.

    Whackjob utopians who, when they got their shot, blew up things so badly that there is now instinctive distrust of government policy in both realms, that no amount of flattening and media puff jobs and gaslighting will override. You should instinctively recoil at allowing either anywhere near the steering wheel.
    schedule 3 weeks ago
Giuseppe Scalas
Giuseppe Scalas
"Now I'm a man.
Now I'm a woman.
Now I'm a man.
Now I'm..."
"A woman?"
"Aaargh! You misgendered me, bigot!"
schedule 3 weeks ago
    Zenos Alexandrovitch
    Zenos Alexandrovitch
    That is the AmCon discord in a nutshell.
    schedule 3 weeks ago
Zenos Alexandrovitch
Zenos Alexandrovitch
Rod, you have no business commenting. You have gaystapo in your own backyard. The discord 'diaspora' you promoted is run by soft-totalitarians who place protecting the feelings of sodomites over protecting children from child sex abuse. Literally threatened to ban an Orthodox seminarian for pointing out the Orthodox moral tradition.

Bringing up the connection between Ukraine and homosexualism, including Putin's direct reference to it in his 2-24-22 justification for the war is banned by mods who say that a fact of record is a lie. Furthermore, the same mod said that it is a lie that Viktor Orban of Hungary attempts to protect children from grooming and that the EU said it was against their fundamental 'values.' Apparently, your discord thinks none of that happened and to ban anyone who brings it up.
So, if you complain about tyranny, why do you also actively support the same BS.
schedule 3 weeks ago
    Zenos Alexandrovitch
    Zenos Alexandrovitch
    Seriously, banned an orthodox seminaroan for quoting Putin's casus belli, because the most was defending the ideology of child rape. Fox&crow supports child rape and is the self proclaimed "evil queen" of your discord.
    schedule 3 weeks ago
      Michael Campbell
      Michael Campbell
      No evidence for that whatsoever.

      Places like that can't function if people are just tossing wild insults and polemic at each other. No one wants to get in to discussion like that - there's no discussion to be had. The same goes for lefties.

      There's a way to civilly broach and discuss just about any topic.
      schedule 3 weeks ago
        Zenos Alexandrovitch
        Zenos Alexandrovitch
        She banned a seminarian for posting about a serious topic complete with evidence, because she thought that pedophilia had to do with her homosexual family.
        schedule 2 weeks ago
Zenos Alexandrovitch
Zenos Alexandrovitch
" He said that all the scholarship winners that year had been subjected to lengthy lectures by the State Department on how their job was to go abroad to spread the gospel of LGBT rights -- this, even though it had nothing to do with the Fulbright program, and in many cases would be diametrically opposed to the cultural views of countries the American scholars were headed to"

This is not allowed on the AmCon Diaspora Discord. Moderator thinks any such suggestion is homophobic and a slur against her 'family.'
schedule 3 weeks ago
    Chris Karr
    Chris Karr
    I think you missed the part where the AmCon Diaspora Discord is NOT moderated or controlled by Rod or TAC in any way. (Not even sure if Rod or any TAC folks actually read any of it.) And when you insist that people who don't agree with you 100% are enabling and promoting pedophilia, don't be surprised when you are shown the door.
    schedule 3 weeks ago
      Zenos Alexandrovitch
      Zenos Alexandrovitch
      You are a slanderer. That never happened. Maybe you are slandering because you have something to hide.
      schedule 2 weeks ago