- The American Conservative - https://www.theamericanconservative.com -

Behind the Emerald City’s Curtains

For many who live in Washington, reminders of the defense and intelligence community’s excesses are in our face every day.  Like Big Pharma, who each night tells “CBS Evening News”-watching senior citizens that they need a new drug, defense contractors know that mid-level bureaucrats ride the subway to work like everyone else.  They constantly pay for large advertisements like this series of Northrop Grumman billboards, which I photographed in a Washington Metro station the other day:

Defense Ads

This week, in a multi-part series called “Top Secret America” [1], the Washington Post confirmed just how large the DC intel complex is.  Though the details in this exposé have been a fascinating read, it’s amazing more hasn’t been made of this runaway federal spending sooner. Since 9/11 and the USA PATRIOT Act, we have been unwilling to face up to the fact that the intelligence community is out of control. Given a blank check after the terrorist attacks, it has grown so fast that—even if Congress wanted to do oversight—a map of the new intelligence complex is indecipherable to even the most able Washington analyst.

As the Post shows, a portrait of the American intelligence community now resembles the justifiably lampooned slide [2] on Afghanistan strategy presented to Gen. McChrystal last spring.  Like this famous powerpoint slide on the mess in Afghanistan, the intelligence community’s organizational chart looks like entangled spaghetti, with duplicated efforts and no central coordination as promised when Congress created the Office of the Director of National Intelligence in 2004.

The Post series begins to fill in the canvas, and it’s staggering how big the pile of spaghetti actually is.  But what’s even more disappointing (but perhaps unsurprising) is the anecdotal evidence pointing to the negative effects of close collaboration between senior government officials and private contractors.  It not only causes the massive waste of public funds, but encourages elites in large sectors of the government and the corporate world to overstate threats to national security.  At one party (I mean “conference”) for defense and intelligence officials hosted by the corporate world

Kevin P. Meiners, a deputy undersecretary for intelligence, gave the audience what he called “the secret sauce,” the key to thriving even when the Defense Department budget eventually stabilizes and stops rising so rapidly. “Overhead,” Meiners told them – that’s what’s going to get cut first. Overhead used to mean paper clips and toner. Now it’s information technology, IT, the very products and services sold by the businesspeople in the audience. “You should describe what you do as a weapons system, not overhead,” Meiners instructed. “Overhead to them – I’m giving you the secret sauce here – is IT and people. . . . You have to foot-stomp hard that this is a war-fighting system that’s helping save people’s lives every day.

The ambiguous “threat” is always present, and so the perpetual War on Terror continues.  Hundreds of thousands labor at public expense to design yet another system that may or may not foil a few terrorists.  As the Post piece points out, one of the most recent attempted terrorist attacks [3] was foiled not by Northrop Grumann—but by an alert airline passenger who noticed something wasn’t quite right.  It was this ordinary vigilant citizen, and not a “war-fighting system,” who saved lives last Christmas day.

Comments Disabled (Open | Close)

Comments Disabled To "Behind the Emerald City’s Curtains"

#1 Comment By Jim Dooley On July 21, 2010 @ 4:07 pm

The DC Metro pictures put me in mind of the “See Something Say Something” agitprop one sees all over mass transit in the New York metropolitan area. Nevertheless, for sheer fear mongering audacity, the palm must be awarded to the I-95 flashing signs that encourage motorists who are just trying to survive rabid texters to REPORT SUSPICIOUS ACTIVITIES. All of which, by the way, goes to explain why the expensive suits down there in Washington allow their s’curity bosses to lead them to the cellars when Grandpa’s Cessna strays into DC airspace. It used to be called brainwashing.

#2 Comment By TomT On July 21, 2010 @ 5:00 pm

Presumably your post is intended to start a conversation, as some recent developments will possibly change the landscape you describe:


#3 Comment By JihadLizard On July 21, 2010 @ 6:10 pm

There are not any peace companies providing campaign contributions to our elected representatives, so there is no incentive to ever end the perpetual wars. First their patrons fleece the taxpayers and then they return the favor and some of their loot to our elected representatives for failing to provide any oversight of their activities. A malicious self-licking ice cream cone indeed.

#4 Pingback By The Big Story: Has America’s spy network grown too big to succeed? On July 23, 2010 @ 4:53 pm

[…] – David Warren: Lacking in intelligence – Joe Conason: Our secret leviathan – Lewis McCrary: Behind the Emerald City’s curtains – Ishmael Jones: Why The Post‘s series […]