fbpx
Politics Foreign Affairs Culture Fellows Program

More Than Bread

Where the pipelines are concerned, the nationalists appear to be gripped by a common delusion that America secretly wants Baluchistan to secede from Pakistan, in order to secure the superpower a new source of oil. Indeed, the uniformity of the nationalists’ expressed grievances and conspiracy theories, is striking. Traditionally, the government found it easy to […]

Where the pipelines are concerned, the nationalists appear to be gripped by a common delusion that America secretly wants Baluchistan to secede from Pakistan, in order to secure the superpower a new source of oil. Indeed, the uniformity of the nationalists’ expressed grievances and conspiracy theories, is striking. Traditionally, the government found it easy to use patronage to divide the warring tribes. Of late, however, a greater coherence has emerged. Last year, the four Baluchi nationalist parties, including three headed by sardars, formed an alliance to put their demands to the parliamentary commission. Also last year, the Bugti and the Marri ended a 50-year feud. No Baluch nationalist seems to condemn the BLA‘s murderous campaign. In his handsome Karachi home, Ataullah Mengal, the third senior sardar—and another grand old man—says: “The armed struggle has begun, the Chinese engineers have been killed, bomb-blasts are going off every day. The cost will be dear, but we are asking for something dear and for that we must pay dearly, even with our lives.”

Another novelty in the nationalists’ campaign is the part played by Mr Bugti, in his blood-splattered town. A former minister of interior and of defence, Mr Bugti is no separatist. He has long sparred with successive governments for money and political influence, and has spent nearly a decade in prison. But the status quo has given him untrammelled power over his tribe and a fund of gas royalties amounting, by one estimate, to 120m rupees a year. Nonetheless, since Bugti tribesmen arose against the government in January, to decry the rape of a female doctor at the Sui gasfield, he has appeared to adopt the nationalist cause. “It’s not all about pounds, shillings and pence. Man cannot live on bread alone,” he told this correspondent—“though I’m sure it was not an Englishman who said it.” ~The Economist (5 May 2005)

Whenever people find the motivations of insurgents baffling, they should look at the now-late Bugti as a good example for understanding how a power player with no incentive to go into open resistance against government can be moved by ideas of defending status, dignity and honour to risk everything by going into rebellion against the very government that made him the power broker that he was.  What Bugti’s radicalisation also seemed to show was that armed, militant Baluchi nationalism has metastasised throughout the community of Baluch nationalists.  It’s not surprising how pervasive misrule can drive people towards ever more radical responses.  Now, if “democracy” ever comes to Pakistan, it will probably only hasten the fragmentation of the country along ethnic lines and subsequently force Pakistan to engage in an internal occupation of territory filled with a well-armed and angry population.

Advertisement

Comments

The American Conservative Memberships
Become a Member today for a growing stake in the conservative movement.
Join here!
Join here