Maybe Icarus Is A Better Comparison


Jonah Goldberg is probably not working from deep familiarity with Cyril of Alexandria, so he probably doesn’t realize how this sounds:

Oprah promised Obama would help us “evolve to a higher plane.” Deepak Chopra said Obama’s presidency represented “a quantum leap in American consciousness.” Last month, Newsweek editor Evan Thomas proclaimed that Obama stood “above the country, above — above the world, he’s sort of God.”

Well, now he’s the god who bleeds, and once you’re the god who bleeds, it’s hard to get the divinity back in the tube, as it were.

Of course, Obama isn’t remotely divine, but if I were trying to make the point that Obama’s absurdly high elevation by his supporters has failed and he has come crashing back to earth I don’t think I would describe him in decidedly Christ-like terms. Yes, I get that Goldberg is making a Star Trek reference, but I am guessing that for most of his audience Kirok is not the first thing that comes to mind when describing a suffering divinity. More to the point, if you want to mock Obama supporters’ messianism, it might help to avoid describing their hero in such obviously messianic terms.

Share      Filed under: miscellaneous, religion

2 Responses to “Maybe Icarus Is A Better Comparison”

  1. Sorry, but does Goldberg have deep familiarity with anything he talks about? Is this someone with insights worth commenting on? This isn’t someone like, say, Douthat, who when he gets stuff wrong, it’s often for an interesting reason. This is someone who, when he gets it wrong, which is most of the time, it’s because he simply doesn’t know what he’s talking about.

  2. Lovely to see dear Cyril getting a namecheck. I love the attitude that that man packed, it’s a pity that there are no clegymen like him left.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.