Will the Medical Marijuana Movement Survive Wal-Mart?


The medical marijuana movement has hit the wall of resistance.It is in the form of one Joseph Casias, a 29-year-old father of two with a brain tumor and sinus cancer who was fired by Wal-Mart for testing positive for marijuana in his system. The State of Michigan says he is allowed to smoke marijuana to ease his chronic pain. Wal-Mart says too bad. It is now Casias’ turn to bring it to court.

To think about it, it probably makes sense that any major progress in the movement — and towards ultimately ending the War on Drugs –  would involve winning a titular battle against Wal-Mart, the socially conservative bastion of globalization’s crudest but most cardinal rewards (cheap stuff, cheap labor and ever-expanding commercial hegemony), which has become synonymous with American culture, industry and even politics. It also employs 1.4 million Americans and runs some 4,300 stores (including Sam’s Clubs) world-wide.

In other words, if the prevailing medical marijuana movement can win its first high profile employee discrimination case – one that involves Wal-Mart Inc. — then it is well on its way to winning the war.

If not, it could be a fatal blow. Because no matter how far the politics and the law has come regarding the ability for sick people to access medical marijuana in their state without prosecution, if the nation’s largest private employer isn’t on board, their medical cards won’t be worth the paper they’re written on.

Let’s face it, the days of “Stop the Wal” are already in the rearview. Politically well-connected and at least partly responsible for the 10-year $186 billion trade deficit with China, Wal-Mart has positioned itself artfully as the savior of modest households strapped by the current recession. In fact they’ve profited from it. Families can buy more, for less (emphasis on more), including food and cheap prescription drugs, at Wal-Mart – and 64 percent of Americans in the last three months have, according to statistics.

And with so many Americans on the payroll, Wal-Mart has its big old thumb on a lot of (struggling) communities nationwide. One big happy family.

Except of course for Casias, who lives in Battle Creek, Michigan. Reflecting the unreconstructed tone of the Republican establishment it has long identified with, Wal-Mart has in effect taken a stand against Michigan’s new medical marijuana law and has unceremoniously tossed Casias — one of its vaunted salt-of-the-earth American “associates” — into the street like so much rubbish.

Now Casias finds himself in a formidable, but probably an unenviable position, having to decide whether to test one of the country’s most comprehensive medical marijuana laws against one of the only places still employing his friends and neighbors in Battle Creek.

But if Goliath can be brought to heel in this epic War on Drugs, to prove that yes, the will of the people in one state supercedes even the biggest global corporate behemoth, then maybe guys like Joe Casias won’t have to choose between their job security and relieving their physical pain, between the well-being of their families and the personal choice not to medicate with narcotics and psychotropic drugs.

Joe Casias

For 11 years, Casias has been living with sinus cancer, which has gotten so bad that it makes his voice sound so painfully obstructed that it is difficult to understand what he is saying. He looks older than his 29 years, his face drawn, his body rail-thin. He is a father of two young children, ages 7 and 8. It is difficult not to get emotionally drawn into his painful story.

Casias has been working at  Wal-Mart for five years and was such a model employee that at one point had been named “associate of the year.” Last fall he was promoted — a proud moment for Casias — which allowed him to finally enroll in the company’s self-funded health care plan. Up to that point, he had been one of the nation’s 40-plus uninsured and was swimming in medical bills and struggling to keep up with collection agency payment plans.

One day during November, he sprained his knee on the job and after being directed to the emergency room for care, was put through a company-mandated drug test. He tested positive for marijuana because for at least four months, Casias had been smoking marijuana – which is legally sanctioned in the State of Michigan –  to relieve his chronic pain in lieu of prescription pain killers.

Claiming that Casias had violated the company’s zero-tolerance drug policy, Wal-Mart fired him on the spot — five years and several pounds of flesh snuffed in an instant.

“I never went to work under the influence – I would never do that,” Casias told me in an interview from home last week. “I gave them everything I got.”

But smoking, he said, allowed him to avoid the pills, which he said were habit forming and had nasty side affects. Coincidentally, 63 percent of Michigan voters felt he should be able to have that option, passing the Michigan Medicinal Marijuana Act on a ballot referendum in 2008. The law allows Casias to carry a medical card and to have up to 2.5 ounces of marijuana, purchased from licensed caregivers, who can legally grow 12 plants at one time.

Furthermore, the law states that people like Casias cannot be discriminated against for medicating legally with marijuana:

From the law:

Sec. 4. (a) A qualifying patient who has been issued and possesses a registry identification card shall not be subject to arrest, prosecution, or penalty in any manner, or denied any right or privilege, including but not limited to civil penalty or disciplinary action by a business or occupational or professional licensing board or bureau, for the medical use of marihuana in accordance with this act, provided that the qualifying patient possesses an amount of marihuana that does not exceed 2.5 ounces of usable marihuana, and, if the qualifying patient has not specified that a primary caregiver will be allowed under state law to cultivate marihuana for the qualifying patient, 12 marihuana plants kept in an enclosed, locked facility. Any incidental amount of seeds, stalks, and unusable roots shall also be allowed under state law and shall not be included in this amount.

“We think it’s illegal to fire somebody for using medical marijuana in accordance with state law,” charges Dan Korobkin, an attorney for the Michigan American Civil Liberties Union, which appears prepared to take on a fight with Wal-Mart. “Firing somebody for doing something that is within the law when they have been a model employee … it’s immoral and wrong.”

This troubling story has drawn swift support for Casias, and similar condemnations from strangers who likely sense some of his acute vulnerability in themselves.  He says he is grateful for all of the outreach, but he is mostly concerned with taking care of his family. “There is really no other job for me to get,” he said, telling me he had once aspired to store manager, even district manager at Wal-Mart.

“Just look around Michigan – there are no jobs. Wal-Mart is one of the only places employing people,” he told me matter-of-factly.

“I can’t pay the bills. Everytime  I look at (my children) … you know there are things children need – clothes, food, a roof over their heads. It’s expensive.”

When he speaks about his former employer is it heartbreaking – there is no malice, but instead a sad confusion about the betrayal. It happened so fast, his apparent fall from grace and re-emergence as a movement martyr, that he has cried openly and is visibly shaken. Why not? He’s not made of China plastic – his fate now, being jobless and swimming in unpaid medical bills, is clearly uncertain.

“I have so many hospital bills in collections. I’m trying to make payments. I finally get on health care and then I lose my job. The thing I don’t really understand is that I tried my best. I don’t think I deserve to get fired. I never harmed anybody, I never harmed any customers or associates, never in the whole time,” he said.

Wal-Mart was so righteous in its move to sever all ties with this heretofore loyal associate, that it initially tired to block his access to unemployment benefits, too. “This is not acceptable ,” said Mike Meno of the Washington-based Marijuana Policy Project, which launched a boycott of Wal-Mart, shortly after the story broke. “This is a guy with kids. Not only is this shameful neglect and immoral, but it is potentially illegal.”

Perhaps sensing the growing public outrage (and with an eye towards pre-empting civil action) the company now says it will not object to Casias collecting unemployment. However, Walmart has no plans to hire him back, recently releasing this statement to the media:

“In states such as Michigan, where prescriptions for marijuana can be obtained, an employer can still enforce a policy that requires termination of employment following a positive drug screen. We believe our policy complies with the law, and we support decisions based on the policy.”

Fee-Fi-Fo-Fum

That Walmart is drawing a line in the sand against medical marijuana – which has been legalized in 14 states and is being debated by at least 16 others today – shouldn’t come as any surprise. Sure, we are outraged by the seeming cold-bloodedness in the company’s statement that it is “sympathetic to Mr. Casias’ condition,” the company at once living up to the long-spun image of the Death Star, grinding up new communities and dispatching misfit employees with detached laser precision.

But the vision of Sam Walton, founder of this empire based out of Bentonville, Arkansas, has never really wavered from the “Gospel of Christian free enterprise,” which is more than not tailor made for the Republican social conservative agenda in Washington. In fact, until this year, Wal-Mart stores and the Walton family had long been generous supporters of Republican federal candidates and causes (they’ve been spreading the love now that Democrats are in charge).  The corporation often wades into political minefields – at one point being accused of openly telling its employees to vote Republican in the 2008 presidential election.

All this to say, that as Republicans in Washington have largely amassed on the side of prohibition where marijuana is concerned, my guess is that Wal-Mart, at least in ideological principle, has likely already shifted there too, along with lawmakers like Sen. Tom Coburn, (R-OK), who thinks most medical marijuana users are fakers and Rep. Mark Souder, (R-IN) who says “smoked marijuana, along with tobacco and alcohol, is the gateway drug for all other drug abuse.”

If that is the case, then Casias’ firing – aside from a cynical move to avoid taking on the poor guy’s medical costs — could be making a 29-year-old cancer patient with two young children an example; an opening salvo in a nationwide fight to resist new medical marijuana protections at all costs.

“I think it is very significant that one of the largest employers in the United States – if not the largest – appears to be taking a position that employees have to choose between their jobs, which they do well, and treating their disease and treating their pain in a way that is recognized under the law. Especially in Michigan, which has the highest unemployment rate in the country now… it’s irrational and it’s illegal,” said Korobkin.

The Michigan Medical Marijuana Association recently organized a protest rally in front of the Battle Creek store. Unfortunately, Wal-Mart typically weathers such public displays pretty well. Except of course, when protests are coming from the Right, then it tends to give in skittishly.

Greg Francisco of the MMMA says Wal-Mart is just the razor-edged peak of a potential ice-berg facing the Michigan medical marijuana movement in the coming months and years. Several towns and cities have filed ordinances to derail the law, despite  popular support and more than 20,000 residents who have applied for medical cards. But he welcomes the fight, which will likely reflect other skirmishes across the country as medical marijuana becomes more legalized, more culturally accepted (a whopping 44 percent of Americans are now in favor of legalizing marijuana altogether) and more threatening to the social conservative status quo.

“I think collectively, it has a positive effect,” Francisco said, because the movement supporters get more publicity the more they have to crowd town meetings to raise a stink. So far they’re waiting for a “test case” to go full throttle against what they say are illegal restrictions being placed on patients under new ordinances.

Casias doesn’t necessary feel comfortable being a test case, nor a David, though he might very well be, in a courtroom, or at the very least, the court of public opinion.

****

Casias asked me quite humbly to tag my piece with this personal note, as he feels that in some ways he is taking more than he can give right now (and other reporters have blown his request off):

I would like to thank the Michigan Medical Marijuana Assoc,. the American Medical Marijuana Association, the MPP and all of the support from bc hydro, cereal city compassion club, kalamazoo compassion club, Greatlakes compassion club and all the people from around the world for their support and prayers but most of all my wife and kids my family and friends and my lord and savior Jesus Christ.

Amen

Share      Filed under: liberties

17 Responses to “Will the Medical Marijuana Movement Survive Wal-Mart?”

  1. Wisconsin held protests at Wal Mart in over 20 cities on Saturday March 27th.
    http://www.examiner.com/x-30194-Madison-NORML-Examiner~y2010m3d28-Scores-of-medical-cannabis-rallies-boost-Wisconsins-Jacki-Rickert-MMJ-Act

  2. [...] The American Conservative » Will the Medical Marijuana Movement Survive Wal-Mart? [...]

  3. No one should ever have to chose between their medicine or their job.

  4. An example of the great difficulties for libertarians of a conservative disposition resulting from the longstanding abuses of government and confusion of corporate status we face today.

    It is no business of government what substance any citizen wishes to use privately for either recreation or medical purposes. Likewise it is no business of government what criteria an employer might choose to impose upon those employed, whether it be racist, sexist, elitist, nose-length-ist or whatever.

    What is the aforementioned right-thinking (libertarian of a conservative disposition) person to do, faced with a conflict like this?

    We face a situation where government has routinely exceeded its rightful powers to legislate in these areas for many decades. We also face a situation where many decades of government regulatory oppression, subsidies both hidden and open, and other interferences with the free exchange of goods and money have encouraged the creation and maintenance of vast corporate structures.

    As is often the case in the real world, it’s a matter of prioritising. The trick is to try to do so on the basis of truth, rather than the all-pervading misinformation and propaganda. Given an accurate assessment of the situation, any decent and honest person must conclude that the number one domestic priority in western nations today, for both ethical and practical reasons, is to end the outrage of prohibition. It is an overstepping of the limits on the rightful powers of government by which millions of people are criminalised, assaulted, deprived of their freedom or property, or even killed, and by which the very fabrics of our societies are corrupted as a result of the pressure hosing of endless floods of money into organised crime.

    In that context, it becomes a no-brainer – the medical marijuana movement is a wedge being driven under the corner of the wall of prohibition, and Wal-Mart are seeking to drive back that wedge. It’s not as if they are either the kind of small employer whose rights should be prioritised by libertarians or conservatives, or as if any victory for them would have the slightest impact on the general run of government interference in employers’ rights to choose whom they employ.

    The best of luck to Mr Casias!

  5. Thank You, Joe C. and Family!

    May YHWH Bless you and Yours with perfect Health, sufficient Wealth, and endless Peace & Prosperity.

    And, may Yahshua Messiah deliver your persecutors from their blindness, lack of compassion and ignorance.

    Be Free

    And, Share the Faith

    P.S. And, double-ditto on the Blessings and all for you, too, Kelly Vlahos, for your righteously well-stated article. You are, indeed, a true Journalist – for the People.

    Blessings to All

  6. [...] to ease his chronic pain. Wal-Mart says too bad. It is now Casias’ turn to bring it to court. – The American Conservative The appointee, Craig Becker, advocates for those illegals so why would he want to punish those who [...]

  7. [...] Kelley Vlahos writes: The medical marijuana movement has hit the wall of resistance.It is in the form of one Joseph Casias, a 29-year-old father of two with a brain tumor and sinus cancer who was fired by Wal-Mart for testing positive for marijuana in his system. The State of Michigan says he is allowed to smoke marijuana to ease his chronic pain. Wal-Mart says too bad. It is now Casias’ turn to bring it to court. [...]

  8. These cases would be more sympathetic if mmj licenses weren’t cynically abused by people who just want recreational drugs. “Wink and nudge” ads for dispensaries are running here in Denver.

  9. Wal-Mart is not at fault. Both the worker and Wal-Mart agreed to a contract. The person chooses to work for Wal-Mart and adhere to Wal-Mart policies. Wal-Mart chooses to hire the individual base upon his not having traces of marijuana in his system.

    There is nothing immoral about this agreement. It could be considered cruel but if you look at the issue from Wal-Mart’s perspective it isn’t so cruel after all. If this fellow pushes a cart into a customer who then sues Wal-Mart under the grounds that Wal-Mart is letting people with “dangerous” levels of marijuana in their system, the Wal-Mart could be taken for millions.

    So instead of blaming Wal-Mart, please blame the insane legal-tort system in the State of Michigan.

    The Pro-Marijuana Crowd (Of which I am one of) has to come to grips with that fact that although legal, the people who use the substance for what ever purposes, may have made binding, moral and legal contracts that may prohibit use of these substances. That is the free world that I among many others would like to see.

    Of course the individual is free to sell his labor anywhere else and there are a lot of employers who will allow his use of marijuana.

  10. There is a want of evidence that a scant indication of marijuana ingestion points to any danger. No pot test measures impairment. To consume pot by direction of a state-licensed doctor yet lose one’s job by a test that doesn’t measure impairment…that doesn’t even happen in N Korea.

  11. [...] Will the Medical Marijuana Movement Survive Wal-Mart? [...]

  12. “There is a want of evidence that a scant indication of marijuana ingestion points to any danger. No pot test measures impairment”

    That’s Nonense there much evidence to show that Pot impares the ability to process information, slows reactions and speed plus makes people paranoid and scared, all of which could affect a persons ability to work.

    This story is yet more proof that single issue libertarians empower the Goverment. The Pro-Marijuana crowd is increasing goverment regulation of business and expanding goverment all just to force acceptance of marijuana and get it legalised. If you truly believed in a free market you would have no problem with an employer telling his employees what substances they can and cannot take. No one is forcing the employee to stay in the job, the employer should be able to give them drug tests or any other tests, if he said in there contracts that there was certain substances or even behaviour they shouldn’t be engaging in. In a true Free Market all discrimination would be legal for whatever reason or lack of reason the busniess could come up with. In the end up these libertarians have shown that social libertarian attitudes always override economic libertarian ideas, so all these people are doing is empowering goverment, the postive law legal system, and creating more leftist regulators and laws in the process. They are handing yet more power to the left.

  13. Nothing venture, nothing gain? superb work.

  14. The difference amongst amateur consumption and medical employment of marijuana begs to be noticed. While I believe that a responsible adult ought to have the right to use marijuana recreationally, I do think, without doubt, allowing for an ill person use of a plant with a long history of medical value should be accepted and legal. Cannabis has a enormous potential as a medication and more awareness and tolerance is called for. In Summary, legalize it!

  15. [...] 29 year old Joseph Casias, a desperate father of two suffers from a brain tumor and sinus cancer. He was given his walking papers by Wal-Mart for testing positive for marijuana. This was legal in his state and recommended by a doctor. It seems the slave labor utilizing, conservative business will destroy all that stand in their way to domination of the global cheap stuff industry. This merciless megalith of monetary might might smash the medicinal marijuana movement right in the mouth. Joseph claimed never to use the prescription when on duty. Still Wal-Mart reserves the right to kick a man when he is down for a smidge of non toxic residue in the fresh lipids. The most fearsome aspect of the case is the power that Wal-Mart wields politically. It could ebb the tide of the medicial marijuana movement with a pharmaceutical filibuster… more here [...]

  16. Cannabis has been safely used as a medicine since the beginning of recorded history, and the pure (and potent) oil of hemp flowers was one of the chief ingredients in the anointing oil used by the Temple high priests of ancient Israel. This is fact, and If marijuana use is immoral, then so were the progenitors of our Old Testament. I live in disabling pain, often incredibly bad, both day and night, due to chronic illness–fibromyalgia that resulted from longterm topical exposure to methanol in the workplace. Addictive oxycodone relieves the pain to some degree, but cannabis is often more effective, and enables me to avoid more harmful presription drugs. I thank God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit every day for His kind provision of such a useful substance.
    It may be true that some people fake their illnesses to obtain a prescription. But in my area the dispensaries are well-regulated and work hand in hand with local law enforcement to keep their operations ethical and transparent; the chiefs of police in the towns nearby also appreciate the fact that no young person will ever visit these dispensaries and leave with heroin, cocaine, MDMA, or methamphetamine. That is the hidden benefit of medical marijuana dispensaries; over the years millions of young people have encountered these destructive drugs for the first time when offered them by a drug dealer they patronized first for the purpose of purchasing marijuana. Even if one chooses to believe that cannabis is harmful, if your son or daughter goes to a well-regulated dispensary, he or she will receive a compound with real medical benefits, and nothing which will destroy his or her life, or land him or her in State or federal prison. Drug dealers tend to be sleazy; people who grow and sell medical marijuana in earnest are very often people like you and me, hard-working Americans with families who often go to Church and contribute to their communities. Sure there are exceptions, but there are exceptions to just about every absolute in this world. I do not use recreational drugs, nor do I personally approve of their use, but if given the choice of living next door to a bunch of drunks, a bunch of political hotheads, or a bunch of pot smokers–everything else being equal–I would certainly choose the pot smokers. When cannabis is accepted, and no longer promulgated as a tool for social rebellion as it once was with my generation, it will cease to be considered a threat. Recent research has shown that it generally does not impair driving to a significant degree by itself (criminals who use marijuana generally tend to mix it with alcohol or other drugs, and mixing drugs without a doctor’s supervision is just plain stupid). Regular medical users generally avoid using cannabis to the point of impairment (except for those who may be in extremes of discomfort, as with terminal cancer patients, and they generally tend to take large doses of pain-killers which pose far greater risks to the patient and to society in the first place, not that a housebound cancer patient poses much risk to anyone).
    Joseph, God bless you. I invite those who agree with me to pray every day for this man and his family. I will not be shopping at Wal-Mart anytime soon; I intend to patronize my local merchants and help them stay in business, for people such as they are, are the backbone of America.

  17. wow interesting case especially since he states he never went to work on the medicine.

Leave a Reply